|
|
沙暴の我愛羅
1 卡尔曼常对人抱怨说,觉得自己应该得诺贝尔经济学奖。
2 当年提出卡尔曼滤波时,主流其实是以维纳滤波为核心的频域滤波,卡尔曼滤波很长时间不被主流接纳。后来,扎德提出模糊逻辑与模糊控制之时,卡尔曼作为当时的主流,即状态空间模型的时域控制和滤波理论的代表人物,成了扎德的最大反对者之一。
3 一手把控制和滤波从频域带进时域状态空间方法的卡尔曼,过去的好多年其实一直在研究频域的一些东西。
4 卡尔曼的贡献包括状态空间系统分析,卡尔曼滤波,可控性,可观性,卡尔曼分解,最小实现等等。和香农一样,他不幸在于领域决定他基本不可能得诺贝尔奖,图灵奖等等,虽然,arguably,已经达到了这些奖的水平。但他其实也很幸运,因为至少卡尔曼滤波方法都是以他命名的。相比之下,知道动态规划是贝尔曼发明的又有几个?反而基于动态规划的维特比算法是以维特比命名。还有,多少人知道H无穷是Zames发明的?MPC呢?最后压轴,谁知道PID是谁发明的?
5 感谢
@pb博 的信息。卡尔曼与扎德后来和好了。虽然卡尔曼公开说过 fuzzy is trash,但两人一笑泯恩仇(这是想象,哈哈哈)。从卡尔曼自己的新理论不被接受,到不接受扎德的新理论,再次说明了,别说是工程界与工程师了,就算是理论界与最顶尖的理论家,对完全跳出原来框架的新理论都如此难以接受。类似的例子还有贝尔曼的动态规划。
6 卡尔曼与扎德其实算是师兄弟,导师都是拉加奇尼(John R. Ragazzini)。拉加奇尼的学生还有Jury。拉加奇尼:Z变换,Jury:Jury判据。
7 岔开一条,讲贝尔曼的动态规划。扎德在 The Evolution of System Analysis and Control: A Personal Perspective
IEEE Xplore Abstract 一文中的对于贝尔曼动态规划的回忆:
In the early '60s my doubts were not shared by many. The ascendancy of mathematical methods was unchallenged, and Lyapounov's stability theory and differential-equations-based theory of nonlinear systems moved to the center of the stage, as did the problems relating to optimal control and systems optimization. The highly original work of Rudy Kalman on controllability, observability, and filtering was at the center of attention. Another contribution of major importance, whose impact transcended disciplinary lines, was Bellman's development of dynamic programming. I became acquainted with Bellman's work in 1954 and perceived dynamic programming as a powerful tool of wide applicability. I suggested to Bellman to submit to the IRE Proceedings a paper describing his work. He did so, but to my embarrassment his paper was rejected by the referees, who felt that Bellman did not provide convincing examples of practical applicability. It is ironic that about 30 years later, Bellman was awarded IEEE's Medal of Honor for his development of dynamic programming.
怎么越看越像在哭诉自己的经历,哈哈哈。
8 在卡尔曼之前,其实不光维纳,扎德,乃至伯德,香农,都也研究过滤波问题。不过,应该说是到了卡尔曼才达到了一统江湖。
9 问题来了,下一个卡尔曼滤波式的结果会是什么?欢迎回答:
有哪些理论可能是下一个卡尔曼滤波似的结果?
10 可能会有争议的一条。有一种说法是,信息论第一代掌门是香农,第二代是Gallager,第三代是Tse。那如果说控制与滤波理论第一代掌门是维纳,第二代是卡尔曼的话,谁是第三代掌门?
11 卡尔曼当然不属于工程师,被工程师认为是做理论的。但数学家也并不承认卡尔曼是数学家,认为他是做工程的。在这一点上,他更像香农,而不是维纳。
未完待续。抛砖引玉,欢迎补充。 |
|